The former Graham’s Market in Sherman closed in October 2022. The building was foreclosed in October 2023 by Five Star Bank. It is currently for sale at $99,000.
P-J photo by Sara Holthouse
A car wash in Jamestown has a new owner.
The Post-Journal/OBSERVER have been analyzing real estate sales in Chautauqua County and recently looked at the sales from Oct. 12-20.
During that time period, EZ Clean Car Wash, Inc. of Jamestown sold 1504 Washington St. to Keith and Jennifer Woolam for $825,000. This is the location of Touchless Car Wash.
There were other business sales as well.
Mark Raynor, Scott Raynor, and Randy Raynor sold a parcel Prospect Road, Westfield to Warren Property Holdings, LLC of Jamestown for $300,000. This appears to be the location of Westfield Mini-Storage.
It wasn’t the only self storage sale. M&R U-Store-It Self Storage, LLC of Cherry Creek sold 2663 Second Ave., Ellicott to C&D Storage Holdings, LLC of Rochester for $50,000.
A referee for Grahams Market LLC of Jamestown sold two parcels in Sherman to Five Star Bank for $123,300. According to village officials, this former grocery store had opened in August of 2020 and closed in October, 2022. The building was foreclosed in October, 2023 and is currently listed for sale at $99,000.
Brabel, LLC of Westfield sold 18-24 W. Main St., Brocton to Domus Fare, LLC of Fredonia for $75,000. The building was previously used as a laundromat and ice cream parlor. Domus Fare is a restaurant in Fredonia. The owners declined to comment on what their plans are for the Brocton building.
There were also two residential sales that topped $1 million. 3166 Chautauqua Ave., North Harmony sold for $1,175,000. 4461 Canterbury Drive, Lot 17, Chautauqua Shores, Chautauqua town sold for $1,085,000.
Including the sales previously mentioned, from Oct. 12-20 there were 16 sales that were $250,000. The remaining top sales are as follows:
— 169 Front St., Lakewood sold for $780,000.
— 32 Foster Ave., Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua sold for $600,000.
— Unit No. 2, South Terrace Condominium, 17 Miller Ave., Chautauqua Institution sold for $454,900.
— Lot No. 16, The Pines at NorthShore, 29 Elm Lane, Chautauqua Institution sold for $385,000.
— 3045 W. Oak Hill Road, Ellicott sold for $350,000.
— 10387 South Boulevard, Van Buren Bay, town of Pomfret sold for $350,000.
— 7595 Sherman-Stedman Road, Sherman sold for $290,000.
— 2637 Shadyside Road, Mina sold for $285,000.
— 6 East Terrace Ave., Busti sold for $265,000.
— 5566 Wilson Blvd., Portland sold $265,000.
— 3050 Riverside Road, Busti sold for $260,000.
— 10363 Main Street, Mina sold for $256,750.
Overall, from Oct. 12-20 there were 144 transactions. The full list of sales higher than $1 are as follows:
OCT. 12-13
A referee for Richard Ford sold 19 Superior St, Jamestown to KeyBank, NA for $61,668.
Mohammad Ayash sold 206 Fulton St., Jamestown to Radha Govind Khatoria for $15,000.
Richard and Cynthia Siegel sold 3045 W. Oak Hill Road, Ellicott to Bradley and Adrienne Barmore for $350,000.
Daniel Borkholder sold 8448 Titus Road, Westfield to John and Katie Byler for $110,000.
Thomas Korcyl Jr. sold 7595 Sherman-Stedman Road, Sherman to Daniel Borkholder for $290,000.
Chautauqua Area Habitat for Humanity sold 44 and 46 Babcock Ave., Silver Creek to George and Stephanie Westbrook for $130,630.
The Administrator of the Estate of Roy Russell sold 201 E. Second St., Dunkirk to Jazmin Gallegos Vazquez for $80,000.
Chautauqua County Land Bank Corp. sold 216 E. First St., Jamestown to El Greco Woodworking, Inc., of Jamestown for $100.
Jane Gross sold Unit No. 3A, Lincoln Park Condominium, Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, to Donald and Sharon Blom for $240,000.
Darryl and Kathryn Mallanda sold 10 Brook St., Lakewood to Owen and Chelsea Murphy for $190,000.
Mark Raynor, Scott Raynor, and Randy Raynor sold a parcel on Prospect Road, Westfield to Warren Property Holdings, LLC of Jamestown for $300,000.
James Torrey sold 69 Wheeler Hill Road, Frewsburg, town of Carroll, to Mark Yost for $126,000.
Tracy Kenzie sold Unit No. 2, South Terrace Condominium, 17 Miller Ave., Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, to 17 Miller Holdings, LLC of Chautauqua for $454,900.
Kevin and Michelle Hilton sold 522 Pine Ridge Road, Busti to James Hilton for $140,000.
A trustee with the Haglund Family Asset Protection Trust sold 366 Miller Valley Road, Poland, to Chad and Lory Buccola for $176,000.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of the late Albert Larson Jr. sold 6291 Magnolia-Stedman Road, Harmony to Robert and Patricia Boham for $205,000.
Roxanne Redick sold 322 Elmcrest Ave., Busti to Lisa Gray for $50,000.
Caroline Melson sold 402 Palmer St., Jamestown to Tracy Miller for $30,340.
Donald and Sharon Blom sold 32 Foster Ave., Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua to Phillip Labowitz for $600,000.
James and Laura Nilson sold 28 Pardee Ave., Jamestown to Stephen Paul Glover Jr. for $135,150.
James and Linda Curtiss sold 12873 Iola Drive, Sunset Bay, town of Hanover to C&L Wood, LLC of Hamburg for $245,000.
Elizabeth Phelps and Robert Duink sold 586 Clymer-Sherman Road, Clymer to Mitchel L and Mindy Ann Einink for $99,000.
Muriel Bramble sold a parcel on Winona Avenue, North Harmony to Beau and Caroline Froebel for $100,000.
Glenda Shareno sold 427 Nevins St., Dunkirk to Nathan Ludwig for $155,000.
A trustee with the Patricia R. Finson Revocable Trust sold Commercial Unit No. 7, St. Elmo Condominium, Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, to Chautauqua Area Real Estate, Inc. of Chautauqua for $130,000.
Liberator, LLC of Medina, Ohio, sold a parcel on Laura Avenue, Ellicott to Doreen Loll for $13,000.
Jan Harrington sold 33 Elam Ave., Jamestown to Susan Philps for $121,000.
Enos and Michelle Neyman sold 134 Park St., Jamestown to Philip and Angella Newhard for $132,500.
M&R U-Store-It Self Storage, LLC of Cherry Creek sold 2663 Second Ave., Ellicott to C&D Storage Holdings, LLC of Rochester for $50,000.
Gregory Rabb sold 518 Lakeview Ave., Jamestown to Kimberly Wick for $80,000.
Patrick and Janice Johnson sold 6 East Terrace Ave., Busti to Andrew Henke for $265,000.
Dennis and Gabriella Painter, and Stephanie Cleary sold 20 Regent St., Jamestown to Frederick Zand for $60,000.
Jeffrey and Ellen Gerould sold 2637 Shadyside Road, Mina to Amy Eberlein for $285,000.
The Administrator of the Estate of the late Eileen E. Downey sold 10284 Rt. 474, French Creek, to Devon McCray for $22,000.
Jordan Eckwahl sold 3524 West Oak Hill Road, Ellicott to Kristina Near for $80,000.
Terry Gray sold 17 Rice Ave., Frewsburg, town of Carroll, to Christopher and Carey Skelton for $225,000.
The executor of the Estate of Joyce Seekins sold 15 Farber St., West Ellicott, to Alexis Cowen for $90,000.
A trustee with the Gambino Family Irrevocable Trust sold 10387 South Boulevard, Van Buren Bay, town of Pomfret to Clifford and Danielle Braun, and Deborah Burger for $350,000.
OCT. 16-20
Paul and Joan Kowalski sold 3156 Rt. 5, Sheridan to Hesham Sawalhi for $118,000.
Matthew Swanson sold 2990 Stone Road, Poland to James and Laura Nilson for $209,500.
James Edwards sold a parcel on Hanover Road, Hanover to Garrett and Jennifer Ball for $15,000.
John Fisher sold 4465 Pickard Road, Ellery to Santos Barrera for $60,000.
Callon and Stephanie Teachman sold 3 Hickory St., Silver Creek to Haley Rose Palmer for $70,000.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Evelyn Farley sold 233 Willard St., Jamestown to Roger and Sandra Bromley for $20,000.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Garland F. Dean sold 27 Colfax St., Jamestown to Lorrie I. Dean Catalano for $7,000.
Jean Marie Seufert sold a parcel on Wiltsie Road, Clymer to William Byler, Hannah Byler, and Robert Byler for $139,900.
Ross Cali sold 3050 Riverside Road, Busti to Kathleen Mazzocco, Timothy McChesney, Stephanie McChesney, Douglas Scholar, and Michael Scholar for $260,000.
Mark Warner and Lori Kooken sold a parcel on Butts Road, North Harmony to Amy Benton for $16,000.
Keith Dunn sold a parcel on Sprague Hill Road, Poland to Timothy Dunn and Dale Dunn for $2,200.
Dale Dunn sold a parcel on Sprague Hill Road, Poland to Timothy Dunn for $3,700.
Kenneth and Nancy Wray sold 265 E. Terrace Ave., Lakewood, to Troy Sasse and Jolie Mandell for $200,000.
Matthew Churchill sold 169 Front St., Lakewood to Julie Ann Lodge-Jarrett and Steven W. Jarrett Jr. for $780,000.
Barbara Lancaster and Mary Brandow sold 7304 E. Main Road, Westfield to Isaac Kasper for $170,000.
Thomas Turner sold 105 Francis St., Jamestown to Andrea Eckman for $4,459.
The administrator of the Estate of Kenneth G. Tilburg sold 5082 Berry Road, Pomfret to Scott Richir for $50,000.
The administrator of the Estate of Shirley Tilburg sold a parcel on Berry Road, Pomfret to Scott Richir for $25,000.
Mary Oleary sold Unit No. D-9, Edgewater Recreation Condominium, Westfield to Nancy Bourne and Colleen McCarthy for $135,000.
Rebecca Haines sold a parcel on Hunt Road, Ellicott to Darlene Kotsi for $32,500.
Maureen Siska sold Condominium Unit No. B-8, Chautauqua Lake Estates, Chautauqua town to Todd Meyer for $150,000.
Deborah Pasierb sold 716 Grant Ave., Dunkirk to William Roum and Amber Szopinski for $72,000.
Mark and Emily Maier sold Lot 17, Chautauqua Shores, 4461 Canterbury Drive, Chautauqua town to Robert and Kimberly Koeth for $1,085,000.
Samuel Saia sold a parcel on Rt. 5, Sheridan to Silver Creek Dev., LLC of Forestville for $80,000.
Darren and Bethany Martian sold 3166 Chautauqua Ave., North Harmony to Kerry and Melissa Bubolz for $1,175,000.
Linda Lewis sold 1106 Prendergast Ave., Jamestown to Jennifer Smith and Cory Anthony for $74,000.
Miguel Vasquez sold 65 Hazzard St., Jamestown to Nikolay and Svetlana Bosovets for $38,500.
Terry Bastian sold 158 N. Pearl St., Frewsburg, town of Carroll, to Wanda Tidwell and Michael Johnson for $40,000.
Frederick Andriaccio sold a parcel on West Fairmount Ave., Busti to James Constantin for $10,250.
Blaydon Niles sold 329 Willard St., Jamestown to Woodlawn Management NY of Jamestown for $18,000.
Jeremiah Brooks sold 10218 West Main Road, Ripley to Alyssa Grimsley and Cody Sargent for $70,000.
Chad Buccola sold 145 Wilton Ave., Jamestown to Nicholas and Kyia Mckane for $125,000.
Brabel, LLC of Westfield sold 18-24 Main St., Brocton to Domus Fare, LLC of Fredonia for $75,000.
Rita and Kenneth Larson sold 264 State St., Jamestown to Karen Lancaster for $150,000.
Diane Galarza sold 5566 Wilson Blvd., Portland to Brian and Pamela Hilliker for $265,000.
Frank and Valerie Parker sold Lot No. 16, The Pines at NorthShore, 29 Elm Lane, Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, for $385,000.
The administrator of the Estate of Arthur Millace sold 856 Weeks Road, Harmony, to Melvin and Marie Miller for $40,000.
Geoffrey and Jeannette Turner sold 37 Jefferson St., Westfield to James Pichman for $32,000.
Eric Schuster sold 27 Kent St., Westfield to Edward and Deborah Grzegorzewski for $174,900.
Thomas Goon Jr. and Michael Goon sold 2424 Falconer-Frewsburg Road, Poland, to Richele Foster for $150,000.
The Supreme Court of Chautauqua County ordered in a judgment that 8947 Main St., Clymer be sold to Leonard Carl Neckers and Mary Jo Neckers for $80,000.
The Supreme Court of Chautauqua County ordered in a judgment that 7354 Main St., Stockton be sold to Amy Jedrysik for $5,775.
A referee for Grahams Market LLC of Jamestown sold two parcels in Sherman to Five Star Bank for $123,300.
Maple Downs Irrevocable Trust sold 8345 Rt. 60, Pomfret to William Smith for $240,000.
Stephany Williams sold 229 Baker St., Jamestown to Michael IV and Stephanie Corrigan for $75,000.
Mark Williams sold 10363 Main Street, Mina to Baronial Splendor Main Street, LLC of Stow, Ohio for $256,750.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Betty Patz sold 715 Lamphere St., Dunkirk to Gloria Ramirez for $57,000.
Thomas and Jamie Safford sold a parcel on Wilber Road, Dunkirk town to J. Joseph Bache and Blair V. Powell for $63,000.
EZ Clean Car Wash, Inc. of Jamestown sold 1504 Washington St., Jamestown to Keith and Jennifer Woolam for $825,000.
David and Tina Gens sold 5803 Rt. 20, Portland to Blake Hollman for $150,000.
Stephen and Donna Ciukaj sold Lot 54, Camelot, 4483 Old Road, French Creek, to Chetan and Amy Hasabnis for $195,000.
Curtis Merle sold 11 Fay St., Brocton to Timothy Lebarron for $157,000.
Michael Mathews sold 82 E. Pine St., Dunkirk to Jill and Christopher Krzyzanowicz for $80,500.
Amy Penhollow sold a parcel on Gerry Levant Road, Ellicott to Knut and Laura Burstrom for $17,500.
James Howser sold 230-232 Hallock St., Jamestown to Jeffrey and Cindy Shannon for $178,500.
Rita Boardman sold 8888 Glasgow Road, Pomfret to Jonathan and Jessica Townsend for $155,000.
The Administratrix of the Estate of John R. Lown sold 4766 Slide-Joslyn Road, Ellery to DD Realty, LLC of Waterford, Pa., for $30,000.
Greater Chautauqua Federal Credit Union sold 9287 Zahm Road, Villenova, to Alexy and Melissa Brumagin for $45,000.
A referee for the estate of Jeffrey Ryan sold 459 S. Main St., Jamestown to Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corp. for $34,006.
